Companion Approval

What each companion likes and dislikes, from every reaction in the story. Big swings first.

Godrick Pendlebrook

Approves (237):

+10: You asked me to tell you when we're wrong
+8: You stood with me while I was knighted, and I named you my fellowship
+8: You stood with me while I was knighted
+6: You said you were sorry, and meant it
+6: You heard me out when I said we'd been leaving people behind
+4: You lit Argynvost's beacon and let the Order go home
+4: You gave Sir Godfrey back the Order's oath
+4: You sat up half the night teaching me to read
+4: You read me what Sir Godfrey wrote on his wall
+4: You took Ireena out of the village, away from him
+3: You stopped the Abbot's wedding
+3: You sent the dragon's last tithe down to the valley
+3: You stood the squire's vigil with Cosmin
+3: You told the Order what their dragon really asked of them
+3: You told me my oath was still mine
…and 213 more

Disapproves (105):

-10: You gave the house one of your own
-10: You offered Ireena to Strahd to buy your own way out
-6: You left two children in the hags' cage
-5: You stood back and let the Abbot give Vasilka to the devil
-5: You told me not to kneel, then
-5: You killed prisoners who had given up
-5: You killed watchmen who had given up
-5: You killed Vistani who had given up
-5: You killed Lady Wachter's people after they gave up
-5: You killed the druids' people after they gave up
-5: You sent Gertruda back up the stairs to Strahd
-5: You let Strahd lift Ireena out of the window
-5: You left the stolen children with the wolves
-4: You let one of us take a Dark Gift from the amber
-4: You let one of us lie down in Vosk's amber
…and 73 more

Kip Smudgewick

Approves (141):

+10: You asked me to hold you to account
+8: You stood by me while I settled up with Mister Quillon
+6: You said we'd be more careful
+6: You let me ask Strahd for his signature, and nothing else
+5: You told me you were sorry
+4: You sealed the Amber Temple so nobody bargains there again
+4: You gave me Strahd's letter when I asked for it
+3: You bound Master Vosk never to broker another bargain in this valley
+3: You sent the dragon's last tithe down to the valley
+3: You told me I was nobody's stock
+3: You told Mister Quillon to leave me alone
+3: You read the small print with me
+3: You asked me about Pip
+3: You told me I'm the honest one
+3: You told me I decide who I am, not the horns
…and 120 more

Disapproves (89):

-8: You gave the house one of your own
-6: You told me nobody asked me
-6: You let me sell my contract to Strahd
-6: You left two children in the hags' cage
-6: You offered Ireena to Strahd to buy your own way out
-5: You let one of us take a Dark Gift from the amber
-5: You let one of us lie down in Vosk's amber
-5: You left the stolen children with the wolves
-4: You told me to mind my own ledger
-4: You sent Gertruda back up the stairs to Strahd
-3: You stood back and let the Abbot give Vasilka to the devil
-3: You kept the dragon's tithe for yourselves
-3: You let Strahd lift Ireena out of the window
-3: You turned on the Vistani in their own camp
-3: You kept what was stolen from the Vistani to their faces
…and 57 more

Liriel Dawnsong

Approves (215):

+10: You asked me to show you the way back
+8: You let me sing the dawn into his chapel
+6: You told me you'd mend it
+6: You admitted we'd lost our way a little
+5: You brought an angel back to himself
+5: You let me remind the Abbot of the sun at the unveiling
+5: You brought St. Andral home to his church
+4: You sealed the Amber Temple so nobody bargains there again
+4: You let me ask the Abbot whether he remembers the sun
+4: You laid Rose and Thorn to rest
+3: You refused to dress a corpse for the devil
+3: You let me tell the false dawn what it was
+3: You lit Argynvost's beacon and let the Order go home
+3: You told me I didn't choose to kneel to Strahd
+3: You saw through my devotional light, and sat with me anyway
…and 193 more

Disapproves (97):

-10: You gave the house one of your own
-8: You offered Ireena to Strahd to buy your own way out
-6: You stood back and let the Abbot give Vasilka to the devil
-5: You let one of us take a Dark Gift from the amber
-5: You let one of us lie down in Vosk's amber
-5: You told me you don't need my hymn
-5: You left two children in the hags' cage
-4: You struck the Abbot down as he knelt
-4: You told me my god isn't in charge of you
-4: You killed a Belview who begged for its life
-4: You killed prisoners who had given up
-4: You killed watchmen who had given up
-4: You killed Vistani who had given up
-4: You killed Lady Wachter's people after they gave up
-4: You killed the druids' people after they gave up
…and 65 more

Ratatouille

Approves (94):

+10: You asked me to help set it right
+8: You sat at my table
+6: You asked me to tell you when we're wrong
+5: You told me you were sorry
+5: You let me cook for the Martikovs
+5: You took me up the mountain to ask Mordenkainen myself
+5: You gave Mordenkainen back his name
+4: You trusted me to step back from the amber myself
+4: You let me tell Strahd I already have a table
+3: You told me nobody could have foreseen Strahd's visit
+3: You asked me what I'd do differently
+3: You joined the Third Circle
+3: You told me the kitchen isn't small
+3: You told me I can go home a wizard and a cook
+3: You promised nothing's going to happen to me
…and 77 more

Disapproves (46):

-6: You told me to suit myself
-6: You gave the house one of your own
-6: You offered Ireena to Strahd to buy your own way out
-4: You told me to keep stirring and keep quiet
-4: You left two children in the hags' cage
-3: You drew steel on a cook in his own kitchen
-3: You left the stolen children with the wolves
-2: You stood back and let the Abbot give Vasilka to the devil
-2: You let one of us take a Dark Gift from the amber
-2: You let one of us lie down in Vosk's amber
-2: You sent Gertruda back up the stairs to Strahd
-2: You drew steel across Strahd's dinner table
-2: You gave a child to the wolves
-2: You sold a child to a hag
-2: You yielded to Strahd in his own castle
…and 14 more

Thistle

Approves (178):

+10: You asked me to show you what a pack does
+10: You lifted the wolf out of Grandda
+6: You said we'd fix it
+5: You told me you were sorry
+5: You took the silver off Grandda and let him go to the high woods
+3: You opened the Abbot's cages
+3: You were there when we said it
+3: You were there the night we stopped racing
+3: You told me I was nobody's dog
+3: You asked me what I'd have done
+3: You beat me at arm-wrestling, fair and square
+3: You arm-wrestled me properly and didn't let me win
+3: You told me to come and find you, after
+3: You told me you'll miss me too
+3: You let me name a star for us
…and 156 more

Disapproves (60):

-8: You gave the house one of your own
-8: You offered Ireena to Strahd to buy your own way out
-6: You told me to go
-6: You left the stolen children with the wolves
-5: You left two children in the hags' cage
-4: You told me to stop sniffing you
-4: You killed a Belview who begged for its life
-4: You yielded to Strahd in his own castle
-4: You handed Emil back to Kiril
-3: You stood back and let the Abbot give Vasilka to the devil
-3: You sent Gertruda back up the stairs to Strahd
-3: You sold a child to a hag
-3: You let Strahd lift Ireena out of the window
-3: You handed the count a roc chick
-2: You let one of us take a Dark Gift from the amber
…and 28 more

Wren Featherfoot

Approves (171):

+10: You asked how to earn my trust back
+8: You let me feel sorry for Rahadin, and walk away
+6: You said we'd watch our hands
+5: You told me you were sorry
+5: You brought me to Kasimir with Master Sorrel's letter
+4: You talked Kasimir out of buying his sister back
+3: You were there the night we stopped racing
+3: You told me I didn't need a joke for what Strahd did
+3: You told me Master Sorrel was right about me
+3: You let me teach you to juggle
+3: You told me you've seen it too
+3: You told me the jokes are part of me
+3: You told me I don't have to be funny with you
+3: You told me we'd do the same for you
+3: You told me to have a joke ready anyway
…and 152 more

Disapproves (68):

-8: You gave the house one of your own
-8: You offered Ireena to Strahd to buy your own way out
-6: You told me it's my loss
-5: You left two children in the hags' cage
-4: You called me a thief for saying it
-4: You killed prisoners who had given up
-4: You killed watchmen who had given up
-4: You killed Vistani who had given up
-4: You killed Lady Wachter's people after they gave up
-4: You killed the druids' people after they gave up
-4: You let me go for Rahadin's throat
-4: You left the stolen children with the wolves
-3: You stood back and let the Abbot give Vasilka to the devil
-3: You told Kasimir about the vestige that could buy his sister back
-3: You let one of us take a Dark Gift from the amber
…and 36 more